Award overlap

Books Recognized by Both the Andrew Carnegie Medals for Excellence and the Macavity Awards

No book has won both the Andrew Carnegie Medals for Excellence and the Macavity Awards. 5 were shortlisted or recognized by both.

Years are award years. Andrew Carnegie Medals for Excellence · Macavity Awards

Recognized by both

Books recognized by both the Andrew Carnegie Medals for Excellence and the Macavity Awards without winning both, most recent first.
BookAuthorAndrew Carnegie Medals for ExcellenceMacavity Awards
The Infernal Machine: A True Story of Dynamite, Terror, and the Rise of the Modern DetectiveSteven Johnson
  • 2025 Longlist (Nonfiction)
  • 2025 Nominee (Best Nonfiction/Critical)
All the Sinners BleedS.A. Cosby
  • 2024 Longlist (Fiction)
  • 2024 Winner (Best Mystery Novel)
I'll Be Gone in the Dark: One Woman's Obsessive Search for the Golden State KillerMichelle McNamara
  • 2019 Longlist (Nonfiction)
  • 2019 Nominee (Best Nonfiction/Critical)
DodgersBill Beverly
  • 2017 Longlist (Fiction)
  • 2017 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
Turn of MindAlice LaPlante
  • 2012 Longlist (Fiction)
  • 2012 Nominee (Best First Mystery)