| A Very Woodsy Murder | Ellen Byron | - 2025 Nominee (Best Humorous Novel)
| - 2025 Nominee (Best Humorous Mystery Novel)
|
| California Bear | Duane Swierczynski | - 2025 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2025 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Ghosts of Waikiki | Jennifer K. Morita | - 2025 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2025 Winner (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Ill-Fated Fortune | Jennifer J. Chow | - 2025 Nominee (Best Humorous Novel)
| - 2025 Nominee (Best Humorous Mystery Novel)
|
| Scotzilla | Catriona McPherson | - 2025 Nominee (Best Humorous Novel)
| - 2025 Nominee (Best Humorous Mystery Novel)
|
| Served Cold | James L’Etoile | - 2025 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2025 Winner (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| The Lantern’s Dance | Laurie R. King | - 2025 Nominee (Best Historical Novel)
| - 2025 Nominee (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| The Mechanics of Memory | Audrey Lee | - 2025 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2025 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| You Know What You Did | K.T. Nguyen | - 2025 Winner (Best First Novel)
| - 2025 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| All the Sinners Bleed | S.A. Cosby | | - 2024 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Everybody Knows | Jordan Harper | - 2024 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2024 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Face of Greed | James L’Etoile | - 2024 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2024 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Play the Fool | Lina Chern | - 2024 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2024 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Scorched Grace | Margot Douaihy | - 2024 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2024 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Time’s Undoing | Cheryl A. Head | - 2024 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2024 Nominee (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| A Streetcar Named Murder | T.G. Herren | - 2023 Nominee (Best Humorous Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Humorous Mystery Novel)
|
| A World of Curiosities | Louise Penny | - 2023 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Bayou Book Thief | Ellen Byron | - 2023 Nominee (Best Humorous Novel)
| - 2023 Winner (Best Humorous Mystery Novel)
|
| Dead Drop | James L’Etoile | - 2023 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Death by Bubble Tea | Jennifer J. Chow | - 2023 Nominee (Best Humorous Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Humorous Mystery Novel)
|
| Devil’s Chew Toy | Rob Osler | - 2023 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Don’t Know Tough | Eli Cranor | - 2023 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| In Place of Fear | Catriona McPherson | - 2023 Nominee (Best Historical Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| Scot in a Trap | Catriona McPherson | - 2023 Winner (Best Humorous Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Humorous Mystery Novel)
|
| Secret Identity | Alex Segura | - 2023 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Shutter | Ramona Emerson | - 2023 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2023 Winner (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| The Bangalore Detectives Club | Harini Nagendra | - 2023 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Under a Veiled Moon | Karen Odden | - 2023 Nominee (Best Historical Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| All Her Little Secrets | Wanda M. Morris | - 2022 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2022 Winner (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Arsenic and Adobo | Mia P. Manansala | - 2022 Winner (Best First Novel)
| - 2022 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Clark and Division | Naomi Hirahara | - 2022 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2022 Winner (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| Razorblade Tears | S.A. Cosby | | - 2022 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Runner | Tracy Clark | - 2022 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2022 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| The Other Black Girl | Zakiya Dalila Harris | - 2022 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2022 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| And Now She’s Gone | Rachel Howzell Hall | - 2021 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Blacktop Wasteland | S.A. Cosby | | - 2021 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Derailed | Mary Keliikoa | - 2021 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Murder at the Mena House | Erica Ruth Neubauer | - 2021 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| The Fate of a Flapper | Susanna Calkins | - 2021 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| The Thursday Murder Club | Richard Osman | - 2021 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| What You Don’t See | Tracy Clark | - 2021 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Drowned Under | Wendall Thomas | - 2020 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Humorous Mystery Novel)
|
| Miracle Creek | Angie Kim | - 2020 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Murder Knocks Twice | Susanna Calkins | - 2020 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| One Night Gone | Tara Laskowski | - 2020 Winner (Best First Novel)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Scot & Soda | Catriona McPherson | - 2020 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2020 Winner (Best Humorous Mystery Novel)
|
| The Ninja Daughter | Tori Eldridge | - 2020 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| The Pearl Dagger | L.A. Chandlar | - 2020 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| They All Fall Down | Rachel Howzell Hall | - 2020 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Three-Fifths | John Vercher | - 2020 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Your House Will Pay | Steph Cha | - 2020 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| A Stone’s Throw | James W. Ziskin | - 2019 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2019 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Broken Places | Tracy Clark | - 2019 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2019 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Hollywood Ending | Kellye Garrett | - 2019 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2019 Nominee (Best Humorous Mystery Novel)
|
| Under a Dark Sky | Lori Rader-Day | - 2019 Winner (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2019 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| What Doesn’t Kill You | Aimee Hix | - 2019 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2019 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Cast the First Stone | James W. Ziskin | - 2018 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2018 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Glass Houses | Louise Penny | - 2018 Nominee (Best Novel)
- 2018 Nominee (Bill Crider Award for Best Novel in a Series)
| - 2018 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Decanting a Murder | Nadine Nettmann | - 2017 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2017 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Design for Dying | Renee Patrick | - 2017 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2017 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Heart of Stone | James W. Ziskin | - 2017 Winner (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2017 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Night Tremors | Matt Coyle | - 2016 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2016 Nominee (Best LCC Regional Mystery)
|
| Stone Cold Dead | James W. Ziskin | - 2016 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2016 Nominee (Best World Mystery)
|
| The Killing Kind | Chris Holm | | - 2016 Nominee (Best World Mystery)
|
| The Long and Faraway Gone | Lou Berney | - 2016 Winner (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2016 Nominee (Best World Mystery)
|
| The Nature of the Beast | Louise Penny | - 2016 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2016 Winner (Best World Mystery)
|
| Young Americans | Josh Stallings | - 2016 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2016 Nominee (Best LCC Regional Mystery)
|
| Ice Shear | M.P. Cooley | - 2015 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2015 Nominee (Rosebud Award (Best Debut Mystery))
|
| The Black Hour | Lori Rader-Day | - 2015 Winner (Best First Novel)
| - 2015 Nominee (Rosebud Award (Best Debut Mystery))
|
| The Life We Bury | Allen Eskens | - 2015 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2015 Winner (Rosebud Award (Best Debut Mystery))
|
| As She Left It | Catriona McPherson | - 2014 Winner (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2014 Nominee (Calamari Award (Best Mystery Set Outside the United States))
|
| Purgatory Key | Darrell James | - 2014 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2014 Nominee (Squid Award (Best Mystery Set in the United States))
|
| The Wrong Girl | Hank Phillippi Ryan | - 2014 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2014 Nominee (Squid Award (Best Mystery Set in the United States))
|
| Nazareth Child | Darrell James | - 2012 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2012 Winner (Eureka! Award (Best First Mystery))
|
| The Drop | Michael Connelly | - 2012 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2012 Nominee (Golden Nugget Award (Best Mystery Set in California))
|
| Who Do, Voodoo? | Rochelle Staab | - 2012 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2012 Nominee (Eureka! Award (Best First Mystery))
|
| Death of a Cozy Writer | G.M. Malliet | - 2009 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2009 Nominee (Hawaii Five-O Award (Best Law Enforcement or Police Procedural))
|
| 47 Rules of Highly Effective Bank Robbers | Troy Cook | - 2007 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2007 Nominee (Best Humorous Mystery Novel)
|