| The Mechanics of Memory | Audrey Lee | - 2025 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2025 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| All the Sinners Bleed | S.A. Cosby | - 2024 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2024 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Hide | Tracy Clark | - 2024 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2024 Winner (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Hot Pot Murder | Jennifer J. Chow | - 2024 Nominee (Lilian Jackson Braun Award)
| - 2024 Nominee (Best Humorous Mystery Novel)
|
| Play the Fool | Lina Chern | - 2024 Winner (Mary Higgins Clark Award)
| - 2024 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Don't Know Tough | Eli Cranor | - 2023 Winner (Best First Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Jackal | Erin E. Adams | - 2023 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Like a Sister | Kellye Garrett | - 2023 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2023 Winner (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Shutter | Ramona Emerson | - 2023 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2023 Winner (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Razorblade Tears | S.A. Cosby | - 2022 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2022 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Runner | Tracy Clark | - 2022 Winner (Sue Grafton Memorial Award)
| - 2022 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Riviera Gold | Laurie R. King | - 2021 Nominee (Sue Grafton Memorial Award)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| The Thursday Murder Club | Richard Osman | - 2021 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Turn to Stone | James W. Ziskin | - 2021 Nominee (Sue Grafton Memorial Award)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| Winter Counts | David Heska Wanbli Weiden | - 2021 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2021 Winner (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Borrowed Time | Tracy Clark | - 2020 Winner (Sue Grafton Memorial Award)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Miracle Creek | Angie Kim | - 2020 Winner (Best First Novel)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| One Night Gone | Tara Laskowski | - 2020 Nominee (Mary Higgins Clark Award)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| The Satapur Moonstone | Sujata Massey | - 2020 Nominee (Sue Grafton Memorial Award)
| - 2020 Winner (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| Three-Fifths | John Vercher | - 2020 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| A Lady’s Guide to Etiquette and Murder | Dianne Freeman | - 2019 Nominee (Mary Higgins Clark Award)
| - 2019 Winner (Best Debut Mystery Novel)
|
| Under a Dark Sky | Lori Rader-Day | - 2019 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2019 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| In Farleigh Field | Rhys Bowen | - 2018 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2018 Winner (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| Heart of Stone | James W. Ziskin | - 2017 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2017 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| The Long and Faraway Gone | Lou Berney | - 2016 Winner (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2016 Nominee (Best World Mystery)
|
| The Masque of a Murderer | Susanna Calkins | - 2016 Nominee (Mary Higgins Clark Award)
| - 2016 Nominee (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| The Black Hour | Lori Rader-Day | - 2015 Nominee (Mary Higgins Clark Award)
| - 2015 Nominee (Rosebud Award (Best Debut Mystery))
|
| The Life We Bury | Allen Eskens | - 2015 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2015 Winner (Rosebud Award (Best Debut Mystery))
|
| How the Light Gets In | Louise Penny | - 2014 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2014 Winner (Calamari Award (Best Mystery Set Outside the United States))
|
| A City of Broken Glass | Rebecca Cantrell | - 2013 Nominee (Mary Higgins Clark Award)
| - 2013 Nominee (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| Live by Night | Dennis Lehane | | - 2013 Nominee (Best Historical Mystery Novel)
|
| Wild Penance | Sandi Ault | - 2011 Nominee (Mary Higgins Clark Award)
| - 2011 Nominee (Hillerman Sky Award (Best Southwest Landscape))
- 2011 Nominee (Watson Award (Best Sidekick))
|