Award overlap

Books Recognized by Both the Goodreads Choice Awards and the Shamus Awards

No book has won both the Goodreads Choice Awards and the Shamus Awards. 7 were shortlisted or recognized by both.

Years are award years. Goodreads Choice Awards · Shamus Awards

Recognized by both

Books recognized by both the Goodreads Choice Awards and the Shamus Awards without winning both, most recent first.
BookAuthorGoodreads Choice AwardsShamus Awards
And Now She’s GoneRachel Howzell Hall
  • 2020 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
  • 2021 Finalist (Best P.I. Hardcover)
Winter CountsDavid Heska Wanbli Weiden
  • 2020 Nominee (Debut Novel)
  • 2020 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
  • 2021 Finalist (Best First P.I. Novel)
The Widows of Malabar HillSujata Massey
  • 2018 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
  • 2019 Finalist (Best P.I. Hardcover)
The SilkwormRobert Galbraith
  • 2014 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
  • 2015 Finalist (Best P.I. Hardcover)
W Is for WastedSue Grafton
  • 2013 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
  • 2014 Finalist (Best P.I. Hardcover)
TakenRobert Crais
  • 2012 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
  • 2013 Winner (Best P.I. Hardcover)
Claire DeWitt and the City of the DeadSara Gran
  • 2011 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
  • 2012 Finalist (Best First P.I. Novel)