| The Fox Wife | Yangsze Choo | | - 2025 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| The Warm Hands of Ghosts | Katherine Arden | | - 2025 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| Where the Dark Stands Still | A. B. Poranek | - 2024 Nominee (Young Adult Fantasy)
| - 2025 Finalist (Young Adult Literature)
|
| Bookshops & Bonedust | Travis Baldree | | - 2024 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| Emily Wilde's Encyclopaedia of Faeries | Heather Fawcett | | - 2024 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| Ink, Blood, Sister, Scribe | Emma Törzs | - 2023 Nominee (Debut Novel)
- 2023 Nominee (Fantasy)
| - 2024 Winner (Adult Literature)
|
| The Ogress and the Orphans | Kelly Barnhill | - 2022 Nominee (Middle Grade & Children's)
| - 2023 Winner (Children's Literature)
|
| Thistlefoot | GennaRose Nethercott | - 2022 Nominee (Debut Novel)
- 2022 Nominee (Fantasy)
| - 2023 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| When Women Were Dragons | Kelly Barnhill | | - 2023 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| A Master of Djinn | P. Djèlí Clark | | - 2022 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| Light from Uncommon Stars | Ryka Aoki | - 2021 Nominee (Science Fiction)
| - 2022 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| Piranesi | Susanna Clarke | | - 2022 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| Root Magic | Eden Royce | - 2021 Nominee (Middle Grade & Children's)
| - 2022 Winner (Children's Literature)
|
| Magic Lessons | Alice Hoffman | - 2020 Nominee (Historical Fiction)
| - 2021 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| Mexican Gothic | Silvia Moreno-Garcia | | - 2021 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| Raybearer | Jordan Ifueko | - 2020 Nominee (Debut Novel)
- 2020 Nominee (Young Adult Fantasy)
| - 2021 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| The House in the Cerulean Sea | TJ Klune | | - 2021 Winner (Adult Literature)
|
| Dragon Pearl | Yoon Ha Lee | - 2019 Nominee (Middle Grade & Children's)
| - 2020 Winner (Children's Literature)
|
| The Ten Thousand Doors of January | Alix E. Harrow | - 2019 Nominee (Debut Novel)
- 2019 Nominee (Fantasy)
| - 2020 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| Bob | Wendy Mass, Rebecca Stead | - 2018 Nominee (Middle Grade & Children's)
| - 2019 Winner (Children's Literature)
|
| Circe | Madeline Miller | | - 2019 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| In Other Lands | Sarah Rees Brennan | - 2017 Nominee (Young Adult Fantasy)
| - 2019 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| Spinning Silver | Naomi Novik | | - 2019 Winner (Adult Literature)
|
| The Changeling | Victor LaValle | | - 2018 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| The Ocean at the End of the Lane | Neil Gaiman | - 2018 Nominee (Best of the Best)
- 2013 Winner (Fantasy)
| - 2014 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| Circus Mirandus | Cassie Beasley | - 2015 Nominee (Debut Goodreads Author)
| - 2016 Finalist (Children's Literature)
|
| Serafina and the Black Cloak | Robert Beatty | - 2015 Nominee (Debut Goodreads Author)
- 2015 Nominee (Middle Grade & Children's)
| - 2016 Finalist (Children's Literature)
|
| The Buried Giant | Kazuo Ishiguro | | - 2016 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| The Darkest Part of the Forest | Holly Black | - 2015 Nominee (Young Adult Fantasy)
| - 2016 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| Uprooted | Naomi Novik | - 2015 Nominee (Young Adult Fantasy)
| - 2016 Winner (Adult Literature)
|
| A Snicker of Magic | Natalie Lloyd | - 2014 Nominee (Middle Grade & Children's)
| - 2015 Winner (Children's Literature)
|
| The Night Gardener | Jonathan Auxier | - 2014 Nominee (Middle Grade & Children's)
| - 2015 Finalist (Children's Literature)
|
| Doll Bones | Holly Black | - 2013 Nominee (Middle Grade & Children's)
| - 2014 Winner (Children's Literature)
|
| The Ghost Bride | Yangsze Choo | - 2013 Nominee (Debut Goodreads Author)
- 2013 Nominee (Fantasy)
| - 2014 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| The Golem and the Jinni | Helene Wecker | - 2013 Nominee (Debut Goodreads Author)
- 2013 Nominee (Fantasy)
| - 2014 Winner (Adult Literature)
|
| The Hero's Guide to Saving Your Kingdom | Christopher Healy | - 2012 Nominee (Middle Grade & Children's)
| - 2013 Finalist (Children's Literature)
|
| Among Others | Jo Walton | | - 2012 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| Deathless | Catherynne M. Valente | | - 2012 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|
| The Night Circus | Erin Morgenstern | - 2011 Nominee (Fantasy)
- 2011 Nominee (Favorite Book of 2011)
| - 2012 Finalist (Adult Literature)
|